1943 Buffalo Creek Road, Lake Lure, NC
$1,625,000 · 6 bedrooms · 4 baths · 2,227 sq ft · built 1968
Listing courtesy of Premier Sotheby’s International Realty (Andrea Battista). Listing data provided by Canopy MLS, deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Bald Mountain Lake provides a distinctively quiet alternative to the more commercial stretches of Lake Lure, offering a level of privacy that defines the high-end mountain retreat. Tranquility Lake House, a 1968 estate, occupies a non-motorized waterfront position that favors silence and ecological preservation. The property comprises 2,227 square feet across two distinct structures, featuring a six-bedroom, four-bathroom layout that accommodates twelve guests between the main residence and a separate carriage house. While the interior is defined by an open-concept vaulted living area and a substantial stone hearth, the asset’s primary value lies in its dual identity as a private escape and a proven short-term rental performer. Buyers should note that despite the secluded setting, the property retains deeded access to the comprehensive amenities of Rumbling Bald Resort, including championship golf and private beach facilities. This combination of turnkey revenue and resort access remains a rare find in the Western North Carolina highlands. Private viewings may be coordinated through Peters & Associates.
About the home
True to its name, Tranquility Lake House offers a rare blend of absolute serenity and powerhouse investment performance. Tucked away on a quiet, non-motorized section of Bald Mountain Lake in Lake Lure, this premium waterfront estate is a turnkey short-term rental managed by Carolina Mornings. The estate features two distinct living structures that comfortably sleep twelve guests. The main home is an open-concept mountain oasis anchored by soaring ceilings, warm wood finishes and a magical stone fireplace. Moments away, the carriage house suite over the garage and game room offers premium privacy. Outside, expansive decking leads to a private dock where days are spent kayaking crystal-clear waters and watching mountain sunsets. Owners and guests enjoy full access to Rumbling Bald Resort's two championship golf courses, private beach, pools and tennis, all set against a backdrop famous for its role in the classic film, Dirty Dancing.
Price in context
- Asking $730 per square foot.
- That is 45% above the $502 median across 20 active $1.5M+ homes in Lake Lure.
- 7th highest asking price of 20 active $1.5M+ homes in Lake Lure.
- 15th largest by living area of the 18 with a recorded size.
- No price changes since it was listed.
- 70 days on the market, listed 2026-06-19.
- County tax assessment $715,000; the asking price is 2.27× the assessed value.
- HOA dues $414 (monthly).
Location
Neighborhood: Rumbling Bald On Lake Lure, Rutherford County, ZIP 28746.
Features
- Levels
- Two
- Construction
- Vinyl, Wood
- Bathrooms
- 4 full
- Basement
- Exterior Entry, Finished
- Fireplace
- Yes
- Kitchen & appliances
- Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Oven, Electric Range, ENERGY STAR Qualified Light Fixtures, ENERGY STAR Qualified Refrigerator, Exhaust Hood, Freezer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Washer/Dryer
- Heating
- Ductless, Heat Pump
- Cooling
- Ductless, Heat Pump
- Garage
- 2 spaces
- Parking
- Driveway, Detached Garage, Garage Door Opener, Keypad Entry
- Exterior
- Fire Pit, Dock - Floating, In-Ground Irrigation
- Waterfront
- Beach - Public, Boat Ramp – Community, Boat Slip – Community, Boat Slip (Lease/License)
- View
- Water, Year Round
- Lot
- Waterfront
- Community
- Business Center, Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Game Court, Gated, Golf, Hot Tub, Lake Access, Picnic Area, Playground, Putting Green, Recreation Area, RV Storage, Sport Court, Tennis Court(s), Walking Trails
- County
- Rutherford
Comparable homes on the market
- 210 S Fork Drive, Lake Lure — $1,390,000, 6 bd, 4,790 sq ft, also in Rumbling Bald On Lake Lure
- 189 Tatanka Trail, Lake Lure — $1,999,500, 3 bd, 3,905 sq ft, also in Rumbling Bald On Lake Lure
- 664 Quail Ridge Road, Lake Lure — $1,250,000, 3 bd, 2,539 sq ft, also in Rumbling Bald On Lake Lure
- 176 Quail Cove Road #1710, Lake Lure — $1,095,000, 4 bd, 1,992 sq ft, 1.2 mi away
- 206 Big Rock Lane, Lake Lure — $1,225,000, 4 bd, 4,296 sq ft, 1.6 mi away
- 167 Hawks Nest Trail, Lake Lure — $1,499,000, 4 bd, 3,870 sq ft, 1.9 mi away
See it privately
Nicholas and Miriam Peters show every home personally. Peters & Associates, 4401 Barclay Downs Dr #132, Charlotte, NC 28209. Office 704-264-4572. Request a private showing.